If you already employ an IT person, the choice is not "replace them or do nothing." There is a third option, co-managed IT, that keeps your internal team in place and adds a provider behind them. The right model depends on the size of your team, how much you have already built and where the gaps actually are.
Here is how the three models compare, how the co-managed split works in practice, and the signs that point you one way or the other.
- Co-managed IT keeps your internal team and adds a provider behind them; fully managed replaces your IT department entirely.
- Fully managed makes sense when you have no dedicated IT staff, or want a single accountable vendor for everything.
- Co-managed fits when you already have one or two capable IT people who are overloaded or lacking security and after-hours coverage.
- The split of responsibilities should be written down, not left to assumption.
The three models, in one table
| Break-fix | Co-managed IT | Fully managed IT | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who does day-to-day support | Hourly tech, when called | Your internal team | The provider |
| Monitoring and security | Rarely | Provider | Provider |
| After-hours coverage | Rarely | Provider | Provider |
| Relationship with employees | None | Your internal team | Provider |
| Cost pattern | Spikes when things break | Lower flat rate | Flat rate per user |
| Best for | Very small, stable offices | Businesses with 1-2 IT staff | Businesses with no IT staff |
What fully managed IT is
Fully managed IT is the classic model: the provider is your IT department. They run the help desk, manage the network, own security and documentation, and your employees call them directly. It is the right answer when you have no dedicated IT person, or when you would rather have one accountable vendor and one monthly number for everything.
The trade-off is that you are handing over the whole function. That is fine when you do not want to manage an IT employee, but it means losing the person who already knows your office and your quirks.
What co-managed IT is
Co-managed IT keeps your internal team as the face of IT, and adds a provider behind them for the things a small team rarely has the budget or time to build: 24/7 monitoring, managed security, documentation, escalation engineers and after-hours coverage.
The split is agreed up front and written down. Typically your team owns day-to-day tickets and employee relationships, while the provider owns monitoring, security, patching, backups and escalation. Projects are shared. See our co-managed IT services page for the full table.
The signs that point to co-managed
- You employ one or two IT people and do not want to replace them
- Your IT person is always firefighting and never gets to projects
- Coverage drops to zero when your IT person is out or on vacation
- Security and documentation keep slipping down the priority list
- You want senior escalation without hiring a second or third engineer
The signs that point to fully managed
- You have no dedicated IT staff and rely on "the nephew who knows computers"
- You want one vendor accountable for everything, including day-to-day support
- You are growing fast and do not want to hire an IT department
- You prefer a flat per-user number over managing an employee and a vendor
Can you start co-managed and move to fully managed later?
Yes, and it is a common path. Many businesses start co-managed to protect an existing IT person, then move to fully managed when that person leaves or when the business grows past what a one-person team can cover. Because a co-managed provider already knows your environment, the transition later is a change of scope, not a new onboarding.
How to decide without overthinking it
The deciding questions are simple: do you want to keep the people you have, and where are the gaps? If the answer is "keep the people, close the gaps," co-managed is the fit. If the answer is "we would rather not manage IT at all," fully managed is.
The NIST Cybersecurity Framework is a useful way to spot the gaps regardless of model: identify, protect, detect, respond and recover. Whichever model you choose, those five functions still need to be covered by someone. A free assessment will show you exactly which ones are falling through the cracks today.